From 8b72327c540520168ee98d57aaf73b2fd07489df Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "ajeffrey@roblox.com" Date: Thu, 20 Jul 2023 14:49:27 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] Responding to comments by jhui --- papers/hatra23/hatra23.pdf | Bin 399296 -> 399414 bytes papers/hatra23/hatra23.tex | 3 +++ 2 files changed, 3 insertions(+) diff --git a/papers/hatra23/hatra23.pdf b/papers/hatra23/hatra23.pdf index e8865fa1aaa9789b7dff074af797b450397df40d..6f01d92a76ff86f57e038474527ed82f1b3cbc99 100644 GIT binary patch delta 6733 zcmV-T8nWfUuNbzl7_e!11UWh~G_!4aQ~?AzIx;kq#dC7`GGbz4Ei^GRWi2={I5;h2H(_OAI5IFbW;bTDzkH?(12{G`mjU+$ zD1V(;OLN;c5WeSE=vHdRfD_^_gX-vxHTmlaRj z6Nv@5*!}j~hr}n_37_1)yIQ`Re{cga30WL+ce30}e90m&ngr5gp7bZn_2kLvY&L2NM9@|}SJ-kwkRO;zk^Z&Q?ed;>?#Gb@ZIDl>k&BcG#yNlszz#nMD9966=()49y) zLE*ar^T$}Is&j&%i$);`JSOAU5%6>@F}z&}jr>KGsd~;@_AH4Hp0hRw6I$g(-BRj= zqN9#WmZA8V);kp2duQvk&40{Qjk$?uH5Z|vWdPj;O2|6T)Tp0of5?)zL6v}tH*ojY zn6?_rAvquc<=F*T@yD%>-|eL-mI#i2tstw`47a3g+ZFEEux+kXj_=3K&xhy@XP zx9d`qx>a4lnU@Qg7s!df?24W zQZSimwh3a2H-BQv(@etbXZSFjLC2#eop@x!^{c?g4(kSB9e8Nx6kI(Dn+xh)SCx4FWV!Aiee(l+E!wSU^t!sA@RtBeES0Z3fuR*yRg z?taSa67U0p2F|)!)uzhn4PAZp^DzOo*6E5?%`CgJ*nZ#5RD&FdTqc6BOM)S% zV<@^p41YQ8kD}L~)U9m-Y>NanD28LmBTYkgJ?3)29ohjddxp!R7YL)m1_CwV0O}dS z)A>d5oav1Ei95?_;9HXCX*-}@WyRLyyKHIxtVISbQefDwEt$LSydpDZXCnb6!S!fH zudIobBw*Tn1ga|l@=>9X=L-M61Y)Y z>Xw6~&*W0$UHD9<-&zKw$=@Sd zf1O5=!+QKwJJk_6B!_RiU&SqrTjw`+3{<~={$b}MX8C=d&@l`A!18T0d%ALH%1v}HKV<7%xE{1rZLV0bcj&@mt!(yaO!6H z?jM%R0NjIWkB4fH0f%aj0*7jk1BYsl1h;CB1y^(fIWjbt!~+H(135A@m*)cp$^tYv zmjU+$D1XgcS#KLhx_#%bs7Gr8b#?94hB1I;S&qC4lI%EfgaJjhBqkKe;o@a}{XM6e zq`J8%q~kjnK+Wo~-q9aKf-_{C^nqtv#NtP*&x_IH8=kErY>=0+b+B z^g&pK5fw(kSh))Vy{kMIXrUF};fq#)V+x@)#!ZmWmx%ydxE4VLi)KJvfFAFGCmIom zB;>#e1kMYO5q++OFEFyR!m-Od3L+_-62YP@Y)fm>8-y!RhC+A)gm~$5lo$l;vKsAN zM1RS4;D|2JA4mMfJc`oqd*nwqNOmbE5JdF;|nb!8C~Ez z`YF&~EQHe_2J&$Mf+z?jdVwLm1wD|4_mCBu_y{JEcR>M|!pDH2abqzm_@#0$B6+ER zKRSiV;BpKmZ$*WHFdBgr7%D~#h^{%1bAR9_J_WD z27eK_@KF_pt@x$@^C&Z1P)fxPwB;8lv(m(b-=v*<=XnL)dh$fbGa+9L&IdvsihoDr zvNP!p`v1t(p7`fKTaSJ>!Q%?Q=Xw5=KbQO&^Jl`J5r5kJ>7;jin|fT=q2kZ)xy@Og z@~2$%l=>WQ?oO|Er|aFFEYJ=3bF+9X7X*wq_ik2uH}&3+_%mJfnOJeV=zUbL`elJ3 zz5a7=GtbwIde4>XX7}l?zhGCno`0ZE5Ogk1g*@s`F4*~#CoOsYZCDC<(!MEM^4Xw2 zDf^Q#?4A`{^0XWerlU?drt?W}-jr9}_QBw*_{1s}))91m(Lx6!w50N;YA;5E>5xt` zJw5IB2k7+^-6a8-yed>x=&CSPVXMMbMTHo4$>O4wKqt(zA>^4nAGQ1AA%Dm3d=v87 znLI2%cRS_jivuB##bh)s8>A*MEqOM*oTTU1-Tt2~c`z7Vm7_#dej$IB$MV@Hl^)22 z&P04NR%LWsPUTt1>D5C9vv*o$dGM(AR4mJK2(Hd_^E)BHo@)?7o*71?;Iar44n8aB zRHDt4F>4WYx|1?{J#9~a9DfMJoJ=Fe%u&FHWDySYFJYVxE_;KoKMsg8K4UcYCM)RH ztj;21N6;BuZ@w_<7-QyQ9;$C^&pNs}q)8vSLAhJA=Cx6U&GKFAo6a>di ztN^d<1H5`!UTgjMth{UYC*4jpZnuB)16A7QnPrR&RAKTiWH|$Jgft7i8QIx+9v;6K zwXde_-uVv(MRs|nipplzF}bu*cZO@7dF3Bat(V$7Zr@zB_c>ta&pM=95cv4(Z%AIU z$V?U{q>=mfr@h|ArhlrgstSEK$QZY%irh2!{XD)XwW$;AzVb_v()1BN-FSE|zPWBLZ_IvIAjjVf%??!6!%8OVXGmVLsMZ%<@Le?Nr%FXUj zkuKb1qm(ryygJufDkaCWNU%Sihk|{QBEKIxc#A0$cz+AzoX{z_*fh;0lmDlYGy5_* zpyq&%IV^*!!wlIfFg=9bp#u+f_-`OWd0vOJ04}C#F#nL2QGhEJyW{E%M#Gwr_Zm?)=&hq{qw2#^c1=~6qs+}VRc!%^i*0L0 zw_R0CN`DGW+P10cQ58{Zo2u{~IU@8nRpDW|=&?;zg{p2VwpyelT>jajswq^a%~ldH zQPFvCOkNuKN+Xl0ColD^q?XBSOfb?=pM2piTAv(a>?h=vyw8!h{Qq7U#TM{Fus(PK zTuy1>oJyrNxhP^3!RAOqtOy7i0jlJgX@T5ew10>&7{e7zQp+sXRf5dO^1P<m$T7s9wma=F-wUg3_pD9Qy)q1hAeS!zz0A?t0fRG({x zF@L0fSXv;6x`0o?J1!Y3U)?i*;WM&3&siTAS-~RDby@Tg$s*6XH1Z;q4w<**daz|Z zlm%Bo@r~XE?Bt?{!F$8?aDJb2&R3=7_gEyZ!E88DVGfnX(}5f=X7wRn%==P%8>;%? z1LuSWQlMnWaZKQmdD62uNQV5QvKlUD&wnll!>BGQ56w&mHM@Y9tF+*a!`#wAO`>wZ zz$Jas!36`CF7kv6Iiy1u)n$Pb^w%Fj?o%}kZF&iMyT=ZbVF@?;e>E6S3x;C_g~dqeFvkQH!n@4>RJO6wkU zEL@@o7r5J?G(Rg#FuRLDSK?bS7m9!;LsNlza$J&4 z@&ddJQ-5w_7@enjBqwq*rKn^SSAUU8pFEpSs^t@*Dv2OD0;rs)vw&!j_oT9EE-H;@ z*}vibhpEh^pvU7{T3(4D=YkEqU)m2SDiLY&1%0M{8@Lur{G18E+i@ep(OhUM+VU$L zM=B{$yVXTknA~CAM|JAX=ON79O_ z^c0EJNiPC4$_MU{z>s<4(UFJOw{ShlZ88efc;~2c$=zT8I_I3`S~+Z=TrGK%Cm9&< zIHr9fJhM(R8LB6j>d-&k9s6)}4=Cx@406Exypm!0upD~s>1Z!_8q<)ym@tY z_Ti`FerM1h4|?rM`#)W~e}7uuOnYrs?6q&k!d5K~X7loWMTZEAqH&z#jys&1dlxao zZx4SiyEnIZG&vH7vigP==;L_O?sYp)`!~H(;N#h(y!!xYx8%oJ8yGdZxNVOZ^&iQ$ z?8|R^)!0W}G%Bjuel%6IZa zo^oG9{vv;cL@#9rbAOGyySBWNrM&*vwY-sC*@L79awz{j9Zbp*`<5d)mJ>O-9hIe= zd>P28{35@}|CFOagKuFMzWw~}8{jV;rp1kgU2GzK*}O*E136&_0j7C@u>` zuj*l_!9yfMTX+gvW1m%Z_Vvo~crY4w@4Coenk4NMD&C*|a(whLku+XU5@rJX1ryWA zDUpdaTYtzK8AE!!&lsHEK$Y8^FkDXIFqZUvjZ1%yEbgk?zrk?b>)D>dSbQpiZ1aSU z?DIg4{C2TbD;?+rk)78R2;8nz4~cA2n&k7SNlB-WM67kyh-k>EDsPRvXzs8@4DuIP zl>Ai?Vp8vWmG1If)4eux>u{#OQ=SQuUv?oz`F{sIuRuSQ;}?nOE~Y!P0MLUZ)_U{> zC+4O%Gq%cEud=3!A1RU~pPsyX6?0Pbm^=NM``^GxIF9?cw}F$Y9{-RsH$vcAM%N-) zO2X!BzK=57F?qeJG#NBk92j~{Z(Nl3WMcwV(T$)&!e>MyKWI?Bft1Z!BR^Lfvn@Hw z7k~FT!gfto>45diBM}1d6Lc2AGGqw$2^MbLS^Zr2`u>0V84$2``UYMu|?_o0zja5!p1UhxpF^%IpP zP;nWQ4mD5^*#cED+a#WIpXVD_VCvmrZhx2;G;#7I<}&x}CZKu?pyoUHxjr*r2CA2V zD&GLA7eHgN1T@A~p!UBBw5TKH(_ACt64DS>k-FWHZc2ccq1t7rT<*9>N)FF?>XvzG zSCRVNk#5Ramyxa*xhXbDKP)5lt4PD{NdIb4X~_Ysu(sIb0OGP;MYRHWceqRG>whvo zSNxN$Ta&E`evOgG-Qg^yo=b4liWgF@&MkKj$E?CxlQi;Z&X{L&rWhQ$@v3_@UYu5{ zw*8i((YxscPLhoh2r<(lV&LiS^iXx@77e>dNBGYN)#)AnH$u9b9qZxg@alO~eiln8 ztETz9=}aLvG@aSrTW%Ft`LFS(rgT#RJ`hdM|FZm-&%mVb^z3 zHEgIfrzeolqr*XG|7_A8P4)biH?_|j zk5c-)R%_$2Mz1OjlCLo*n=B!Jxb4L<&G#o>U962gqsiA^Z9HHV>b2&Fcz<1}ym@4N9234ZC7*%Mkf-m#X-o3GHBvdvd$Soxef zxcSJnS_^cQxvR<`)4y3%rFlqfYx;qYLN%q=Bn!_F0D6O)R^@6IXZYrBq^9nPQ~YO+ znKj&$Z{WA&`*At1EI)M1FE`}~)-}(%pFBYhJ|6bk-+-_(tLm6M98&-0QQ6;@pG&VIh zF*Y$ZH8?plFflMD+|jt(wvP9lPcU_i(q z=-?2)=Ujd~$8qn$aUvoy6-g5n=ar2+Bn}Zv)a{Cx^1wDIIKT^A-~<=s!zNhZhDz9g zIEaU8Sce2igd`Qukhv`xQXm!5ARRIwe-pAG8*-o!3RDu#&466UgISn?Iaq`RSb-&2 zhA_;-s!Gq1nNk5w&+ZPz)td3T05P61X+0xl% zir9*P?Cik;_M#H+1jHc1!UB@wViE$P5@7NF4r>s^#-^b=xReMBEH07Og9U)+84r7| zNRoH{<@07h0>gW7SRvq*_g`$Kzp2j~kZO^BQqcced{J>pJXxrv zIeRO;-LMj0dEI}JC$N@1DgSk);W}iOfLgLwgD?itms{=Ez;pPxW7a+&=mW8o3^(nD zoG?6eY#80ych$8~QAuu}`JThsgpebFs>N6lMORCGBk-e_#)aijy z7iH(uI8I=Zy@j3B@+TzmKUt_{>!B0Da}~+S?ix7@k9tjp0T>%m2}hH4aI*&|Q6IUh zXVWs{NtV#}se9+95O{-p!PmVS*jnw=)J!A!5`_)uB$QLO!4%;#Aq{6hNQF-wwhNEg zri%!9R~?W~Pu_`H-cl!~y0C0b2#kN;tB*^%wanE02p3t7#{1yxmoG`W-`)E=Q=wjF ziuA=_ii5W^iWY?c4X;bH>NtZ7() zFu8ii@tx+`8HeureLb$iN*4h4O1K zXk0(^_B?~HNDzz^M2aj zFn7N%@D!DU!x{~@!1N0T*%w_ny2sQF3 zfptGTg{T;%c)N_1^oOgx#j7A2ZlqKw;W(Nve%|}d*Z!Si5r3_TTHgBurN3O7@9()P zNF~=+I~KWIZQbB}37V^wZTJKNIQ#3H#EyGejMoZG+KyMwIyi`5#AA<;QUPc)s&ASX zU&b}t8npcG{8V@xoLYsjvf%V;_%?xq@ zngjUROo5#a{zqnnq? zSnCFw0)8BY_54?jkvQ|4$rx-KfMIVS)|IjbIMuUbh?9STc zxKbNP ztLCjI7{AuuC#+I1%p2LrR5wJr^9%jjQ7vFsg11SRBXvS+vlowJIN#j9tR7kFt4qxK zm5_DONIum`D@)u_{=Pv`ih0T7VdT7^znxl3ika{Q#2D% z65-ry;VBY3Hm;9ZN59s4Tgn=Yq0>f9dEsC2D{lrBQdz7-GQJxdr(WJ#yFEyEM-`{x z0N00ppYsh9s-0fXfEe`+r@ksJqjHC1~v z&MNs_uJP~FcfWn~o1O_SDkC=G?5Q(%u5UcHQ+49!mci(c@0hjANQ|T8L@aw^!;#0B zXiwS~HZOH&)%Fm&p8h?9lh-!s=zFH~msnL~XgImBDz;hVvl>Ijl!TC}GVgN(O0e{& zG@xaQ#KP4F6%D>=gNymt7O%2#^RI8xvR0>%@m1pr4%B;^HizK2ZRt{&Y=Xrb7oZjf z4>h*Hj?gvg{C*P38L9(tNyDv!ea*E-u>ivy1U(o7&6jTP`fwJYy$fze zT^|0;LEHOY0S?P34E+byMbq_vImFlh>=cCd{&9$e|3hv8)slc(?K9@$z-~ZbkZ%*0 zTuEcA>(?klW@Qh1WU%YyFIx@z!9PNL29l0_%6gB@)~{ZCV40@RZx8E-2R<0!%{^b@ ziE!`mGgsf9_YVy4I1IV0{+;{=b?PV|qY+rYwNic){tn!fEl-@gcjJ?PJb1%@Qb0By zC{zU3f9>K3@~7}|{VZYxT0S34X#QYL$RSof6%Z_qu;0r>(Yv(9X@)%iGh= z+V%gLyNwee1jH)L>K<{D9CMP4@gJD~f%PBQEhou1a^6^CqToznY+Tm=6@6^n5loQe z|9;GIQ)hh!$nxWfWkIraS)Iv^5wOXSEt0rR@0Dowu#V|~*e2b(hAwn{_mhlry=IG0 z!Z3Pm8My4(Qlh-qCZ|WlN2p6!q)1spO$h&$K+!m5wAk0! zNHK3(&{;RV?YD&$sQmoZbZGs;M_=#0PhxOcVh88sAimFrQNmh)J=amIdc-p>e8YRz zs=frm2CJGr9E<}b02}HM1-n(^>k-j)NDQFhoD${gfiAF@TZs_Ia@?LX`>SzarbJ>& zhV=w&i4+Mno;?Ri@iD4W_k{0Fhd+;(ILMesFA&g7<0gP!#cFlEB6_Y4B7Uw>Eo$R`{}eEz+$SMj~~E}j^FyNGxXuy0dD5Q)48?D z;@ZUVbT>I)v{7JWwslho$iLYB!tyRe<5uLCatzDbl?#lb-v^sYE+l4ik@>R7L`O}` z9h~;F678M0I*qyZiN!d6#i_T)ALP@Zwl-VAa`vtrk*)Z?6CsQAd#vyI#Qd+V;q9)o zeP`N;U0U$H#GBYklgTL_0KA=iP@egU8^-yBR#ndr>8OsBJ}@&BxO0)rGKd(a4Vg?5 z2rx^G`KjAN54tVpaYx2mz}#;QgKcPth)CNdox^(YIUK)Nti(@y1dg(1pX8I`D(F1^ z@KAkLI+Qq)IFUG3Y^OmRxTZt6_VL!X%Bkbk zpwM!Gl>wP+q(+$`gYJv9{5U)Fb$KLcf;)&I=w}kKvr&usZW3Yz zKk+7RdoWCRpo#7w-5q2~8`{IcJ<$B#8Wh_Zk!d0mB64&!C}$)y6zdB0aV?;pq$K6V ziO|D1n7%3B>wmq)+#O1BQ;F)e75ko5`sxZRg(^(cdiC31YF4HpK) zjW&GIZFXgfS6{I&2>rbNXJq4@iBMC(YFqpMk!Rn@S09xo&a?A{4V~|e>PGb*Y>CT$ z!pAq05OKO2}+GNdL&3 zpqn&b!xG7e%^?lALOyp5v0A_LfctxFU@1|My|U@Q1X{KW2F#ji**xQv>yr8xLC=Xm zG0gt4KL0uGuqac3Ftc5K#A4H~tflak&-dq^Fu5s#qpdRZJ$1;`hT}P1M1y422VmK^ z{E5OHqn{qDU{$bn=*xQ6TEaHzl{J(gB{xl?g8EYTUXJ zCGJ{=R?ndef_v<4>VZag0jjRm*V#gxok3^%iVa*)a-AZ60&XB}lfdxu|(P zUP!)O_}aNN)ln+d-Q$$`$0L&Bq4l^?{wQ+zsCahKr+;NB4fmor#$Q8|fC;K|{f!rH zf9r!Ky*CR;{*fpSX`2B|@l$*Xljt3vg;C~{e}58GT+;Z*Etti{PE5$od5yV)w<=d> zppSfH@;o3_ZV{(C74vkNGTmE*F8uX6%Bj&({`}RqvId{g`Y_4#y0Ls!tz+)UjOlX; zd>vWY5<3`DS>r&&&(ZRmuz)&*ufXJZd6jp$ly4?ezW1Bv0;aioQ=6wFC10XwsYTnY zda4Os!?$)7{SOz@c}=nq?nP|?@UHXK^u@m*Yib7F1=KY;t_P$fN}<%wS(B}GlG=r> zwTX)LEVREHmW|^ZFd8>-&NR|~YVu?;z$tDj{Lcf+}E%5*R?a#)Hn-)ED;oqREbq+{ye$BL8M>jCkIS0{N`Rs}qM7izS|E693} zWxg&Lt+trIj2?Z}JZ9D)0{3y8+Eb#xjAyvE`w`sADC~dh9QvgkZ2BwUcPfFi2@k)( zZ^C*ZU522Xz}K<{ZlluCFKq(kyi093oBa!x?XeM(*` zAFmQeQM--Phd3A6>U zjz%)>dQJXyPs(QRabw3L@K-MT{V z_Q(5cTPu5$@W3^xT4>rjBJgLnSvSON^rxVJbEZ&-0R{m)dS>I?PP6Rm@iABAC#U56Z1y}Gw8u! zrT{j+fIE1tdH`2YJ((uiPW8i$w`2vhSU}m6pU2Zv1_^}RiGJ3E>HDKp{Z^23BypykU#g^t;yBiIf(^vOz9_>|qV_G&YymD-EjEy4VCvNH4 zOYJP4Dq|{zgo3`ZU2l0~n|5X_Y`E1{VkG<_yW7(s!%}f5NVwV+9M9|8p>wmILlNDb zy1=(+_8w=gL%d+;+XtnYB1x5#S$3;`frB69oepk5Vh`z0b-$kDTais)#}pY0$uW!j ze5lo?HJ|t(za(Y%ZhHNUz+56&-u3DuR8nMA_Wd(1mY;uMIYrm7QI=uVv}3%TXcQ{V zxLY9mHhQ+l@Q0g)aCPL=er_0|Rfv4nQvrT<1I46&IsSz^1h#p(8360$jTB_qkrrDO zOgQO6+y_KFmjSTkNk96ZUF??)FPyhb1hN$}F3*JxN=YXp$^+@0hRCC)s8jmpf4~gQ zgCCuwnUe-ObD0k^xz)+ks7{mN5b4{jH}thI0=}@dp}t0R>d`97YoB-L=n_%Xw_D1Hqci^`#xt?R2jAv7023{?Zr%bh z{>(&ajJyP$W?VpHv8_IUeLmXBR&3S)Vp1fSgXf})dq*U#_5{Qi$-c=`z40&qJ&|*_ z?qT1p&y1gH$=sK4aieH~@e*u@15Mf@J^ zO#-nIktMq)PPaf$Xzn*r#gU!g`+u5@(}H8mTNdby9Z^1)dS%Zy{Og4~U&`z!4p2a8 zdN=Rd^*ioL{6yNAFE!pB1ibujmX$16H_J(U`aiVJ3mIg*N*_gdmxqOqP?!HYA~`p^ zmtJkf)R$x2jrMs>!INw)s1BcW!$h_`bLvvaKjgc#Lj=;5UyvXIF&Y!pUyXWFl|Q;; zCi)bA&o#Aeixi7AEI!#%0aNvi>Kuz2xcRNJl|=4|`izP;RjNFqQrwVlGgE3L+dk$t zvSg&(8y0VEsr+-&cjSFm6)WLJ_-v=%GTjO147DYgUOReW_EEd}L=)azdMmDFASxmuBJ=U~Ru&tnYuMO=wvawj1`7#25d%}^Uiv)!*-^04mC%g~vtMa~HUgpq^z z*m0SUwZPe5Oo@*Q7`Nce=pv~HHA*C;Yx3P(Fv4Rfmx zow5Wqk6o_4H#VN%%|AywCrjkl5MEncQhXPjWv-FJ`VD&l*TO^0k^V#3eXNjjxYXj? z-zzIK54l;pb;s_$8al$SW|&-5ry5sgEp@qkj=P(sj|cwRHt!rJ*wHaUn*B7$-m)v( zR9z538|9`}%S)ZlhH({RT+Qf2jd#0iU2K1%s`sFslnpjBbSG~?|9vlh$}e|?6q>_d z7q4yqD*c*7K(_1HuM5N4w=x*YjN#~UT~2>A1fDDQ!XO6>!1OnaB7$E)_oGaoScsro zxS3)6m=u|3RJaxjN@Bv2Vv0~vkc5(mup|_s1Q7v4!D5P#*J5Chq@uhmtMvb`l9@t{ z3x+ezK!hT7DMPos>~|Rkx)MKZWPdyT+vWa_<*%M&tUN~nO=90yR`!%wt=gGe40!;h zBAYJYtg|KHVtsYhD~FH$qKtjI@RxMUd%t*vA1{15NHw`oq5w%&oQxg@l5xGbShh`I&wj6E}@(q))dUQoDNao$lch?DF3F(%0^?>)mCW^JRbkP44()Nq`6$Umc-y n9VtUy#r$c+